Banner Post

Disputes over Non-Compete Agreements (NCAs) & Non-Disclosure Agreements (NDAs) when Senior Personnel “Jump Ship”

In a competitive business environment, personnel moving to work for competing enterprises, especially senior personnel, may pose considerable risks to their former enterprise. Given the nature of their positions, this group of personnel often has access to important information such as business strategy, customer data, pricing policies and technological secrets, among others. Such information can create a significant competitive advantage if exploited by another enterprise, especially a direct competitor.

To limit these risks, enterprises often establish Non-Compete Agreements (NCAs) and Non-Disclosure Agreements (NDAs) with their personnel, especially senior personnel. However, in practice, establishing and enforcing these agreements may give rise to many disputes concerning their validity, the scope of obligations, and the parties’ liability in the event of a breach. This raises legal issues that need to be considered: To what extent can enterprises establish and enforce non-compete and non-disclosure agreements? When a dispute arises, what must an enterprise prove, and what legal measures can it apply to protect its legitimate rights and interests?

Source: Pexels

1. Typical dispute situations when senior personnel “jump ship”

NCA and NDA disputes often arise when senior personnel move to work for a competing enterprise or use information obtained in the course of working at their former enterprise. Based on the contents of the documents previously entered into between the enterprise and its senior personnel, typical situations include:

a. Personnel moving to work for competitors

After terminating their labor contract, senior personnel join a competing enterprise despite having previously signed an NCA. Disputes typically revolve around whether the employee has breached the non-compete commitment and whether the enterprise has grounds to require the employee to bear liability under the agreement, such as penalties for breach or compensation for damages.

b. Personnel using or disclosing confidential information of the former enterprise

Employees copy, transfer or exploit without authorization information of business value, such as customer lists, transaction data, pricing policies, business plans or technological secrets, to serve operations at the new enterprise. Such conduct may give rise to liability under the NDA and under the laws on intellectual property, competition and personal data protection, depending on the nature of the information and the manner of the violation.

c. Personnel soliciting customers, partners or former employees

After leaving, senior personnel may approach customers, partners or former employees to divert transactions, establish cooperation, or recruit for the new enterprise. Disputes may arise if the employee uses confidential information or engages in unfair competition to achieve this purpose.

However, the above acts need to be distinguished from lawful competition. Employees remain entitled to use the knowledge, skills and professional experience they have lawfully accumulated and to maintain personal professional relationships; approaching customers or recruiting former personnel does not automatically constitute a violation.

2. Legal basis and key issues to note when resolving NCA and NDA disputes

a. Legal basis and the possibility of recognition of non-compete agreements

One of the contested legal issues is whether an enterprise has the right to require an employee not to work for a competitor for a certain period after the termination of the labor contract.

According to Article 10 of the Labor Code 2019, employees have the right to freely choose their employment and to work for any employer and in any place not prohibited by law. This provision raises the question of the legality of agreements that restrict employees from working for competing enterprises after leaving their jobs.

Conversely, enterprises have the right to protect their legitimate business interests, especially business secrets and technological secrets. Clause 2, Article 21 of the Labor Code 2019 allows an employer to agree in writing with an employee whose work is directly related to business secrets or technological secrets on the content, duration of protection, benefits and compensation in the event of a breach.

However, this provision does not directly govern restrictions on employees working for competitors after termination of the labor contract. Therefore, there are still differing approaches in practice to the validity of NCAs. Some take the view that an NCA may infringe the employee’s freedom to choose employment, while others hold that the parties are free to agree, on a voluntary and equal basis, in order to protect the enterprise’s legitimate business interests, provided that the content of the agreement does not violate legal prohibitions.

Notably, in Decision No. 755/2018/QĐ-PQTT – the source from which Precedent No. 69/2023/AL was developed – the Court examined the voluntariness of the parties in entering into the agreement and found that the employee had full capacity for civil acts and was not coerced, deceived or subjected to an imposition of will when signing the NDA. On that basis, the Court held the NDA to be valid in the specific case. At the same time, Precedent No. 69/2023/AL recognizes the approach of treating confidentiality and non-compete agreements as agreements independent of the labor contract, falling within the jurisdiction of commercial arbitration where the statutory conditions are met and a valid arbitration agreement exists.

However, precedent does not automatically recognize the validity of every NCA. The legality and enforceability of each agreement must still be assessed on the basis of its specific content, the principle of freedom and voluntariness in making commitments under Article 3, and the conditions for the validity of civil transactions under Article 117 of the Civil Code 2015.

b. Conditions and limitations on enforcing confidentiality obligations

Compared with NCAs, confidentiality obligations have a more specific legal basis in Vietnamese law. In addition to Clause 2, Article 21 of the Labor Code 2019, enterprises may also rely on the provisions on the protection of business secrets under the Law on Intellectual Property to protect their information.

The parties may agree in the NDA on the scope of information to be kept confidential, including customer lists, pricing policies, business plans, transaction data or other internal information. Such information may be protected on the basis of contractual obligations, without necessarily satisfying the conditions for protection as business secrets.

However, if an enterprise wishes to protect information as a business secret under the Law on Intellectual Property, the information must simultaneously satisfy three conditions under Article 84: (i) it is not common knowledge and is not easily obtained; (ii) it is capable of creating a competitive advantage when used in business; and (iii) it is kept confidential by its owner through necessary measures. Therefore, the fact that information is listed in an NDA does not mean that it is automatically protected as a business secret.

Notably, Point c, Clause 1, Article 127 of the Law on Intellectual Property identifies a breach of a confidentiality contract in order to access, collect or disclose business secrets as an act infringing the rights to business secrets. Therefore, depending on the nature of the information and the violation, the employee may be liable under the NDA and, if the statutory conditions are met, also under intellectual property law.

In addition, if the confidential information contains personal data, enterprises need to consider the corresponding obligations under the Law on Personal Data Protection No. 91/2025/QH15. Copying, providing, transferring or using personal data in violation of regulations may give rise to independent legal liability.

However, an NDA cannot be used to monopolize all of the knowledge, skills and professional experience that employees lawfully accumulate in the course of their work. To ensure enforceability, enterprises need to clearly define the type of information protected, the scope of use, the persons permitted access and the duration of confidentiality, and to implement corresponding access management and control measures.

3. What should enterprises do when they discover that an NCA or NDA has been breached?

NCAs and NDAs are usually drafted to cover a broad range of content, including acts deemed to be violations, prohibited matters and the conduct the enterprise expects. At the time the documents are established, the senior employee also agrees to, or at least does not object to, the contents of the NCA and NDA. However, that does not mean that all contents of the NCA and NDA are valid, as we have analyzed above. We therefore believe that enterprises should not wait until they notice signs of violation by senior personnel before examining which provisions of the NCA and NDA are binding. Rather, from the moment the NCA and NDA are established, enterprises should already anticipate real-life situations and the corresponding response measures, and determine which provisions are merely deterrent in nature or which anticipate future legal developments, and which are permitted by law. When a violation actually occurs, enterprises will need to take several steps, such as:

a. Verifying violations and collecting evidence

Enterprises need to review the NCA, NDA, labor contract and related commitments to determine the employee’s obligations, the scope of protected information and liability for breach.

At the same time, they need to check for unusual signs such as copying of data, forwarding of internal emails, downloading of documents before leaving, or use of the enterprise’s information to serve activities at the new workplace. Evidence may include system access logs, download history, emails, data from company devices, and records of the handover of assets and documents.

For electronic evidence, enterprises need to retain the original data, document the collection process and ensure the integrity of the evidence. Inspection and collection must be carried out lawfully, without unlawfully infringing on the privacy or other rights of the employee.

b. Applying appropriate legal measures

In practice, depending on the position and role of the senior personnel and on the seriousness and impact of the violation on the enterprise, most enterprises choose to handle the matter at escalating levels, such as: sending a written notice to the employee, sending a letter to the enterprise where the employee is now working, or initiating a lawsuit.

Where there are sufficient grounds, the enterprise may claim a contractual penalty or compensation for damages in accordance with the agreement and relevant legal provisions. If the violation simultaneously infringes business secrets or intellectual property rights, the enterprise may consider applying measures to protect its rights under the Law on Intellectual Property.

The choice of remedy should be based on evidence, legal grounds and the ability to prove damages, rather than relying solely on the general commitments in the NCA and NDA.

4. Recommendations for enterprises: Prevent proactively rather than merely responding after personnel leave

For senior personnel, job changes are hard to avoid. Enterprises therefore should not rely solely on NCAs and NDAs to prevent risks, but need to build mechanisms to protect information and business interests as part of personnel management itself.

First, develop NCAs and NDAs suited to each group of personnel. Enterprises should clearly determine the persons to whom they apply, the scope of information to be protected, the duration of confidentiality and liability for breach. For NCAs, it is necessary to consider the scope of industries, competitors, the time limit of the restriction and the corresponding benefits for the employee, avoiding provisions that are overly broad or lack a basis for enforcement.

Second, choose a dispute resolution mechanism at the time of entering into the agreement. For disputes arising from NCAs and NDAs, enterprises should consider choosing commercial arbitration as the dispute resolution mechanism, especially where these agreements are established independently of labor contracts. Compared with the labor dispute resolution mechanism, arbitration takes a more flexible approach to independent civil and commercial agreements between the parties. Precedent No. 69/2023/AL is an important reference point for this approach. However, enterprises need to ensure that the agreement satisfies the conditions for validity under the law, especially in terms of voluntariness, the content of the commitments and the independence of the agreement.

Third, strengthen the management and control of internal information. Enterprises need to classify information by level of confidentiality, restrict access rights according to job functions, record access history, and have measures in place to control the copying, downloading or transfer of data. This is not only a risk-limiting measure but also a basis for proving that the enterprise has applied the necessary measures to protect its business secrets.

Fourth, establish a process for handover and revocation of access when personnel leave. When senior personnel end their employment, enterprises need to carry out the handover of documents, equipment, accounts and related data, and to revoke access to internal systems, email and information management platforms. Enterprises should also require employees to confirm the return of assets and their continued compliance with confidentiality obligations that remain in effect.

Fifth, establish a response process for when signs of violation are detected. Enterprises should have a mechanism for receiving information, examining and preserving evidence, and coordinating among the human resources, information technology and legal departments. Preparing this process in advance helps enterprises respond promptly and reduces the risk of the information continuing to be exploited or disseminated.

5. Conclusion

Senior personnel moving to work for competitors is a business risk that enterprises can hardly eliminate entirely. However, enterprises can proactively control and mitigate this risk by establishing appropriate legal commitments and building effective mechanisms to protect internal information.

Enterprises should not rely solely on NCAs to prevent senior personnel from moving to competitors, particularly given that Vietnamese law does not yet fully stipulate the conditions and limits for enforcing this type of agreement. Instead, the focus should be on protecting legitimate business interests, business secrets, technological secrets and data that enterprises have the right to manage and protect.

A rigorously constructed NCA and NDA system, combined with mechanisms for access authorization data control and a process for handover and revocation of access rights upon resignation, will help enterprises not only reduce the risk of disputes but also establish the legal basis and evidence needed to protect their legitimate rights and interests when violations occur.

📩 BOOK A CONSULTATION WITH CDLAF’S LEGAL TEAM

Do not let procedural errors disrupt your business plans. Contact CDLAF today to receive a preliminary risk assessment from our team of Lawyers:

Hotline/Zalo: [+84 909 668 216]

Email: info@cdlaf.vn

Why choose CDLAF’s service?

  • We provide effective and comprehensive legal solutions that help you save money and maintain compliance in your business;
  • We continue to monitor your legal matters even after the service is completed and update you when there are any changes in the Vietnamese legal system;
  • Our system of forms and processes related to labor and personnel is continuously built and updated and will be provided as soon as the customer requests it;
  • As a Vietnamese law firm, we have a thorough understanding of Vietnam’s legal regulations, and grasp the psychology of employees, employers, and working methods at competent authorities;
  • CDLAF’s team of lawyers has many years of experience in the field of labor and enterprises, as well as human resources and financial advisory.
  • Strict information security procedures throughout the service performance and even after the service is completed.

You can refer for more information:

Schedule a consultation

We are committed to keeping all information you provide confidential. However, submitting this form does not establish an attorney-client relationship between you and us.